Monday, October 27, 2014

Is Breeding Your Mare the Right Decision?


Babies are soooooo cute! Don’t you just want one? Everybody does.
You really love your mare, and she would make you such a cute baby.
She’s your most favorite horse, you’ve had her since you were both young and she’s not getting any younger. They don’t make them like her any more.
They are all valid points of consideration, but are they enough in this world of unwanted horses. Everyday you hear about neglected and abused horses. See horrific pictures of horses in starved and awful conditions. Sometimes even from so called rescues. Does your mare have the right stuff to make a baby that will have a future?
To consider taking on the responsibility of a foal should require careful thought that includes the future of the horse beyond being that cute fuzzy little foal into a rambunctious yearling and two year old and on into a productive adult. What will this foal’s job be as it ages? What is the market for this foal if you don’t keep it? Can you afford to care for, train, and develop the horse for the market?
All things to think about, but seeing those cute fuzzy little things playing in the new spring grass can cloud person’s judgment.
Some breed associations have gone so far as to structure the selection of the mares and stallions for breeding, such as the Hanoverians. Their selection criteria can be found at http://en.hannoveraner.com/home/breeding/breeding-program/breeding-programme-for-show-jumpers/selection-criterias/
Selection Criteria for mares
1. Mares with a breeding value evaluated from the data of the mare performance test of at least 125 points and with a score of at least 8.0 for free jumping or
2. Mares, whose dams and sires take part in the program for breeding Hanoverian show-jumpers and who received a score of at least 8.0 for free jumping in the mare performance test or
3. Dams and full sisters of horses which are internationally successful and are ranked by the World Breeding Federation for Sport Horses (WBFSH) or
4. Mares with own show records and/or with show records of their offspring.
The Friesian horse registry is even more selective and the rules can be found at http://www.fhana.com/regulations/details.php?unid=72, and are very detailed about the levels of registry for both the mares and stallions including show record and pedigree considerations as well as designations of registry in the Foal Book and the Stud Book, Star Mare and Model Mare, all in the efforts of improving the breed.
The 6666 Ranch of Texas, known for it’s production of cow horses for the working ranch, race track and the show pen has gone so far as to publish a list of criteria on their website that includes:
The decision to retain a broodmare is based on the following:
1.Conformation
2.Pedigree
3.How well (gelding) siblings perform, usually on the ranch
4.Her show or race record, if shown or raced
5.Siblings' show or race records
6.Quality and performance of offspring (retention over time)
Further information about their breeding program can be found at 6666ranch.com/quarter-horses/quarter-horse-mares.html
In an effort to bring this subject to a more personal and local level I asked to a few of my friends, that have experience with breeding, raising and showing horses, for their opinions.
The first breeder I spoke to is Elizabeth O’Briant, owner and operator of “In Time Arabians” of Mingo, NC.  She named her farm this back in the 70’s with the hopes that “In Time” she would breed, raise, show and sell national quality Arabian and half Arabian horses. In pursuit of knowing a quality horse she is also an open show judge and is certified to judge in hunt seat, saddleseat, western and non trotting horses. Most recently she has also started her raising own racing quarter horses.
She started breeding Arabians back in the 1980’s, at a time when the market was flourishing and Arabians were selling for large sums of money.  Many people were in the breeding business, but In Time Farm is not a big farm, and had to be quite selective in the 2 to 3 mares that she bred every year.  Through trial and error she learned much about the breeding game. Most importantly, just because you have a beautiful mare and you breed her to a beautiful stallion it does not mean that you will get a beautiful baby.
“I think the mare contributes more to the baby than the stallion, so therefore I spend more time finding the best mares. Although no horse is perfect I try to find mares with very few faults.  I study the pedigrees first.  The most important lineage in a pedigree is the “female tail line” or the mares dam line.  I want to see what these mares have produced.  If they have produced champions then I’m off to the next step.  What kind of faults does my mare have?  Does she have crooked legs or club feet?  If so I don’t breed her because they will pop up sooner or later.  I consider these major faults.  If I am breeding for a saddleseat horse then the mare I am breeding had better have a nice high set on neck with plenty of leg action.  If not, then I will not get a saddleseat prospect.  What about a western pleasure prospect?  I want a horse that is extremely quiet and built to do the job.  I would never cross a high headed horse hoping that her baby would have a western pleasure frame or I would never take one of my race horses and breed it hoping for a western pleasure horse.  Disposition and trainability are as important to me as conformation.”
In Time Farm has bred horses that have won over 10 national titles with over 20 top ten awards.  These awards were in halter, western, hunter and saddleseat.  The competition and the quality in the show pen gets tougher every year.  The first thing she breeds for is quality and conformation.  It takes a very pretty horse to win unless it is a timed or scored event. She has crossed American Saddlebred mares on Arabian stallions, liking what each breed has to offer. With this cross she hopes for a halter horse that will go on to make a performance horse.  Saddlebreds tend to be a little long backed so therefore she is going to cross on a shorter backed Arabian stallion.  She also hopes that the stallion will pretty the head up. Saddlebreds usually have great length of necks and although an Arabian does not have the length that the Saddlebred does, the Arab has a nice shape to its neck so the foal will hopefully get a long neck with a nice shape to it.  The American saddlebred has beautiful movement so by breeding the mare to a very big moving “English type” Arabian stallion she hopes to get the movement too. No one stallion or mare will give you everything.
Further she explained “If I’m crossing for a Half Arabian western pleasure horse then I’m going to cross the Arabian on a quarter horse because the quarter horse is a more stock type breed. If I am breeding one of my quarter horse race horses then I am going to breed a mare that has a great speed index to a proven race horse stallion. I’m not breeding because the stallion is sweet or because I like his color. I’m breeding for the racing discipline. When it comes to selecting the right stallion you need to research his pedigree as well. How well has he produced and what has he produced.  Have his babies been marketable?”
The second breeder I spoke to is Amanda Benton of Rowan Creek Farm, Ivanhoe, NC. Amanda began showing in 1987 in the stock breeds in the varied classes of all-around, western pleasure, hunter under saddle and driving, as well as some hunters, dressage. She then moved on to breeding and showing her own quarter horse foals. She recently moved into the miniature arena with great success, showing to 4 American Miniature Horse Association World Championships, 3 reserves and multiple regional championships.
Amanda explained, “When looking at broodmares a good mind is first and foremost. A bad minded mare will typically result in a bad minded, difficult to train foal. I believe it's not all genetics as much as it's what the mare teaches her foal from birth to weaning. Conformation is second. Some flaws I can overlook but a good mind I cannot. A mare needs to be suited to purpose. I am especially picky when it comes to feet, legs and gait. A crooked legged foal may get around the show pen a year or two but eventually limb deformations, even minor flaws, can and will cause soundness issues and eventual retirement from the show pen. Beyond mind and conformation I prefer mares that are pleasing to the eye overall, balanced and correct. A kind, soft eye to me is very telling of a mare's personality as well.”
When asked how a mare’s pedigree figured into her choices she said, “Pedigree is often a deciding factor for a lot of breeders and while a strong pedigree can be a plus when selling a prospect it's not a deciding factor for me when choosing a mare. Many world champions have been bred to a world champion only to produce a mediocre performer. And the other side of that coin are the stellar performers who came from no-name parentage. I don't put a large amount of emphasis on pedigree.”
Over and over again you can see that there are several factors in common when people and organizations consider breeding and the selection of the mare. When you’re thinking about breeding your own mare, other considerations can be the cost of maintaining your mare and then the foal, loss of productive time while your mare is carrying and caring for the foal, and then the training and continuing care of the foal until it is of an age that it can be usable, and the possible loss of that mare. What is the cost of all that compared to shopping for a foal that is what you want already delivered and ready to go at weaning? As a yearling? Two year old? Finished adult horse that is ready to go down the trail or into the show pen?
Babies can be a fun and exciting experience that I know personally, but I also know that it is an expensive hobby and if you don’t have a market for your animals you shouldn’t be breeding. Some people can actually make money in the industry, but usually it’s the law of averages has finally worked in their favor. Think long term for your horse. Where do you want it to be in 5, 10, 15, 20 years? With good care horses can live a long and fruitful life being enjoyed at all stages of their life if they are a horse people want. Think carefully when you consider breeding, are you creating a horse that people will want, visit some online rescue sights to look at the pictures, and make sure you want to make the commitment of bringing another horse into this world. 
Written by Anne Wicke, Sampson County Extension REINS Volunteer
 


No comments:

Post a Comment